Dreamsongs Wiki


AbolishTutorials

BjornFreemanBenson gave the Diagnoses that tutorials were part of the problem. Others have complained that InsidersDontWantToPayForTutorials.

Perhaps we should abolish tutorials as extra-pay events.

This will require a major upheaval in the budget. However,

we could then have more 1.5 hour events and fewer 3 hour events.

Insiders would be more likely to go to these special events.

We could call them tutorials and require people to register,

but registration would be because attendance would be limited

and not for the purpose of gettting money.

We'd have to raise the regular conference fee. This won't

bother people from industry, who are getting tutorials for

free. But it will bother academics.


We could have the usual two-tiered conference pricing: one for academics, another for industrials. Not very ACM, I admit, but very in tune with what happens in the real world. --BjornFreemanBenson

Academic Pricing? Yeah!. As a academic from outside both the EuroZone and DollarZone, I heartily aprove of this idea. The Academic housing scholarships went sone of the way towards this (are they back this year?)


JamesNoble


Agile Development Conference has one high fee that buys you a pass to any tutorial. (Academics and students get a big price break.) I thought it would be a disaster, but it worked well. There was not gross misalignment of space and attendees, people didn't stay away because of the high price, and the end-of-conference retrospective (2003) showed people liked it.

I've only ever paid for one tutorial in my life because I'm a cheapskate. I was glad I went to the ADC tutorials. - BrianMarick


Raising the regular registration fee WILL bother many industrial participant. mdv


Given that tutorials are paid for, I suggest we are more careful about selecting reviewers for tutorials. Rejections based on one sentence "I do not know what this is about" are rather unprofessional. mdv

Is the point to change the "pay structure" or to abolish tutorials?

I'm infavour of the former, but not the later since tutorials attract both new blood (those who want to learn), and experienced professionals (with best-practices to share in return for a revenue/marketing opportunity).

-StevenFraser


I agree about the importance of Tutorials, but even with careful criteria, they can be a real shot in the dark. I too have stopped attending unless I already the presenter, and more than just a reputation. but for many, tutorials with a conference are a "cheap" way to justify attendance to the boss. unfortunately. -- CeciliaHaskins